Last 12 months, to 10 November 2026 · Attribute correlation analysis
Top 10 Return Value
£186,603
14.2% of the £1.31M total
Avg Return Rate (Top 10)
52.5%
vs 47.1% brand average
Fit Score Below 40
6 of 10
Problematic or poor fit
Too-Large Skew
7 of 10
Returns skew too large
Ranked by return value. All return rates are adjusted (pre-return window, logistical issues excluded). Fit Score runs 0–100; higher is better.
| # | Style | Return Value | Return Rate | Fulfilled | Fit Score | Size Skew | Return Reasons |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | £37,712 | 70.2% | 1,146 | 21 | ← Too small |
Fit 68%
Consumer 21%
|
|
| 2 | £27,675 | 61.0% | 1,058 | 65 | Too large → |
Fit 46%
Consumer 45%
|
|
| 3 | £17,207 | 55.9% | 556 | 13 | Too large → |
Fit 67%
Consumer 18%
|
|
| 4 | £15,856 | 45.7% | 772 | 63 | Balanced |
Fit 54%
Consumer 27%
|
|
| 5 | £15,627 | 80.0% | 485 | 25 | ← Too small |
Fit 72%
Consumer 23%
|
|
| 6 | £14,921 | 52.9% | 442 | 7 | Too large → |
Fit 75%
Consumer 12%
|
|
| 7 | £14,763 | 42.7% | 363 | 47 | Too large → |
Fit 56%
Consumer 28%
|
|
| 8 | £14,510 | 33.8% | 1,910 | 59 | Too large → |
Fit 69%
Consumer 20%
|
|
| 9 | £14,414 | 47.1% | 493 | 32 | Too large → |
Fit 65%
Consumer 22%
|
|
| 10 | £13,919 | 56.2% | 580 | 38 | Too large → |
Fit 62%
Consumer 28%
|
Four patterns stand out across these top-returning styles. Each insight is grounded in the data above and the category-level benchmarks below.
Fit-related reasons account for 46–75% of returns across all 10 styles, well above the consumer and quality categories. This isn’t just a high return rate — it’s a fit return rate. Six styles score below 40 on the Fit Score, meaning their sizing is actively causing problems for customers.
7 of 10 styles have a positive size imbalance, meaning customers are returning items because they run too large. The Thessaly Woven coat (+0.99) and Tribeca coat (+0.93) are nearly entirely too-large returns. Only two dresses (DS1141 - Bluff and Philomena) skew too small.
These two categories hold 9 of the 10 spots. Coats & Jackets account for 5 styles (£77k in return value) despite having a lower category return rate (47.4%) than Dresses (61.8%). The high unit price of outerwear amplifies return value even at moderate return rates.
8 of 10 styles launched in AW25, suggesting a possible batch-level fit issue in the autumn/winter collection. Only one style dates to AW24 (Tribeca) and one to SS26 (DS1141 - Bluff).
The top-returning styles in each category outstrip their category averages.
| Category | Styles in Top 10 | Their Avg Return Rate | Category Avg Return Rate | Category Fit Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coats & Jackets | 5 | 48.9% | 47.4% | 40 |
| Dresses | 4 | 66.2% | 61.8% | 46 |
| Trousers | 1 | 33.8% | 46.4% | 44 |
Note: Cordelia’s return rate (33.8%) sits below the Trousers category average, but its very high volume (1,910 units fulfilled) pushes its return value into the top 10.